The efforts of the CPSC to reduce kids’ exposure to lead is the reason that Fisher-Price and Mattel recently settled on a $2.3 million fine for the toys they had manufactured in China in 2006 & 2007 and which the CPSC recalled in 2007 for being over the legal lead limit. It was Congress who stepped in after that episode to strengthen and broaden the existing laws with the CPSIA of 2008.
While the new regulations further decrease the amount of lead and phthalates across an enormous range of products (which is great) what you have left out is the fact that Congress, backed by powerful lobbyists, crafted a law that is so broad and far-reaching that along with reducing the amount of unsafe items on the market, in effect, they are also reducing the amount of SAFE and NATURAL products on the market through regulations that require product testing, certification and labeling that small batch manufacturers simply can’t afford. (Think home crafters: wooden toys, hand-knit sweaters, custom baby blankets, slings, clothing, accessories, specialty products for the learning disabled, etc.). If you are not a fan of mass-produced goods, you may soon find yourself with no other options. Not because small companies’ products are non-compliant, but because they can’t afford to prove them safe. Sadly, the irony of this situation is that the Big Guys that caused the lead scare in the first place by mass-producing and importing tainted goods are the ones who can afford to comply with the law and who will benefit from fewer competitors, while the small companies offering an (often natural) alternative to those products will soon be forced out of business.
It should also be noted that because Congress made this law retroactive, it’s now illegal to sell used clothing and other goods for kids under 13 without first testing them for lead! This does, in fact, include garage sales, ebay and craigs list! You can find all the details on the
CPSC’s website:
http://www.cpsc.gov/about/cpsia/cpsia.html
and user-friendly answers to common questions here:
http://www.whatisthecpsia.com/
While well-intended, this law could be made better by keeping the limits on harmful substances, but allowing small players a more reasonable and affordable method to prove compliance, such as component testing. Tell Congress it’s great that they are trying to protect our kids, but if they could do it without destroying family businesses, that would be even better.